DIY Cat Toys: Quick Fun for Happy Cats

Keeping your cat entertained doesn't require a shopping spree at the pet store. With a few household items and a little creativity, you can craft easy DIY cat toys that provide mental stimulation, physical exercise, and hours of fun while saving money and reducing waste. This guide walks you through simple projects that are easy to make using cardboard, fabric, and recycling bin finds, plus food-motivated puzzles that challenge your cat's problem-solving skills.

The Importance of Play (and Why DIY Cat Toys Matter)

Play satisfies your kitten's natural hunting instincts. Without these regular outlets, cats often develop behavioral issues like excessive scratching or overgrooming from sheer boredom. Additionally, 33% of cat owners categorized their pets as overweight or obese,¹ highlighting how crucial regular activity is for maintaining healthy weight through a cat’s life stages.

Homemade cat toys offer a generous variety of cat enrichment at zero cost. Research shows that less than half of cat owners engage in interactive play with their pet on a daily basis,² making accessible and fun DIY enrichment options even more valuable. 

Fast Fun from the Recycling Bin

Your recycling bin is actually a treasure trove of DIY projects for cat enrichment toys. Here, we’ll share inexpensive, zero-skill projects that tap into what kittens love most: You can make cat toys with interesting textures, sounds, and stalk-and-rush³ movements that trigger their hunting instincts.

The Cardboard Tube Battling Buddy

Transform an empty toilet paper roll into an interactive puzzle feeder in minutes. Simply fold one end closed, use a scissor to cut holes around the tube, add homemade treats inside, then fold the other end shut. Your kitty will bat it around to release treats or kibbles, satisfying their problem-solving instincts while getting rewarded for their efforts.

The Sock and Catnip Mouse

An old sock becomes one of the best cat toys for wrestling and kicking with minimal effort. Stuff it with fabric scraps and a pinch of catnip, then pin, tie or sew the opening securely. The soft texture mimics prey, encouraging your cat to grab, kick, wrestle, and chew, which is perfect for zoomies.

The Crinkle Paper Bag Tunnel

A paper (not plastic!) grocery bag creates an instant hideout that cats find irresistible. After cutting off any handles for safety, simply lay the bag on its side. Cats love both the crinkling sound and the secure feeling of having a hiding spot for ambush play.

Building Enrichment and Puzzle Toys

Moving beyond simple toys, food-motivated puzzles challenge your cat's mind while making mealtime more engaging. These cat enrichment activities help slow down fast eaters and provide mental stimulation that can be just as tiring as physical exercise.

The Egg Carton Treat Dispenser

A cardboard egg carton makes an excellent beginner puzzle that encourages natural foraging. Place treats in each cup and close the lid, letting your cat figure out how to access the food. This simple setup keeps them busy for extended periods while satisfying their instinct to hunt for meals.

The Box Maze Fort

Cats love boxes as they provide places to hide, play, and even scratch and bite.⁴ Cardboard boxes become adventure playgrounds with just a few strategic cuts. Create entry and exit holes large enough for comfortable passage, or connect multiple boxes with glue or tape for elaborate tunnel systems. This setup provides secure spaces for hiding while engaging your cat's territorial instincts.

String-Based Teasers (Supervised Play Only)

Do you have loose pieces of string around your house? For interactive play, tie string to a stick and attach feathers or fabric scraps to create a classic wand toy. You can even add a small bell to make it more engaging. This setup mimics bird or insect movement, triggering intense chase and pounce instincts. Critical safety note: Always supervise string play and store these toys away afterward to prevent accidental ingestion.

DIY Cat Toy Safety & Supervision Guide

Not all homemade toys for your cat are safe for solo play; some require your direct supervision to prevent accidents. Understanding which toys to leave out and which to put away keeps your cat safe while they explore and play.

Here's what you need to know about toy safety:

Key safety principles also include avoiding small detachable parts on unsupervised toys you can make and inspecting all toys weekly for wear. When in doubt, supervise play until you're confident the toy is safe for solo use.

The Connection Between Activity and Wellness

Observing your cat during play gives you valuable health insights that extend far beyond entertainment. Changes in energy levels, reluctance to jump, or reduced interest in favorite activities can signal pain or other health issues worth discussing with a good veterinarian.

This monitoring mindset extends beyond playtime to bathroom habits, where PrettyLitter makes health tracking simple. This innovative color-changing cat litter responds to urinary abnormalities by shifting colors, providing early alerts to potential health changes. While not a diagnostic tool, it offers peace of mind by helping you monitor for early signs of potential health concerns.

Tired of your
home smelling like
you have a cat?

TRY NOW – JUST $14.99

Use code BIGDEAL

Monitor Your Cat’s Health with PrettyLitter

Creating DIY cat toys strengthens your bond while providing endless entertainment using simple household items. By rotating toys and prioritizing safety, you ensure playtime stays fresh and engaging throughout your cat's life stages.

Combining active play observation with proactive health monitoring through PrettyLitter gives you a complete picture of your cat's well-being. For even more inspiration, explore the best cat toys your cat will love to keep your feline friend happy and healthy.

Sources:

1. Association for Pet Obesity Prevention. “2024 Pet Obesity and Nutrition Survey Highlights.” https://www.petobesityprevention.org/2024-survey. 
2. ScienceDirect. “Identifying barriers to providing daily playtime for cats: A survey-based approach using COM-B analysis.” https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0168159124002685#sec0005. 
3. PubMed Central. “Making fetch happen: Prevalence and characteristics of fetching behavior in owned domestic cats (Felis catus) and dogs (Canis familiaris).” https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11373866/. 
4. RSPCA South London. “How to enrich your cat.” https://rspcasouthlondon.org.uk/2024/04/17/how-to-enrich-your-cat/.